All Pins

Shamrock Pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Coffee Shop

Music Note Pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Pizza Parlor

Plant pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Dance Lounge

Pizza Pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Plaza

Balloon Pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Dock

Lantern Pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Night Club

Beach Ball Pin
Rareness: 10/10
Location: Ski Lodge Attic

Sun Pin
Rareness: 9.5/10
Location: Book room

Horse Shoe Pin
Rareness: 9.5/10
Location: Mine Shack

Astro Barrier Ship Pin
Rareness: 9.5/10
Location: Snow Forts

Hockey Stick Pin
Rareness: 9/10
Location: Ski Village

Soccer Ball Pin
Rareness: 9/10
Location: Gift Shop

Pencil Pin
Rareness: 9/10
Location: Book room

Light House Pin
Rareness: 8.5/10
Location: Plaza

Telescope Pin
Rareness: 8.5/10
Location: Mountain

Pirate Flag Pin
Rareness: 8/10
Location: Pet Shop

Pumpkin Pin
Rareness: 8/10
Location: Dock

Jet Pack Pin
Rareness: 8/10
Location: Beach

Life Ring Pin
Rareness: 7.5/10
Location: Lighthouse

Camp Fire Pin
Rareness: 7.5/10
Location: Ski Lodge

Christmas Tree Pin
Rareness: 7.5/10
Location: Club Penguin Newspaper

Candy Cane Pin
Rareness: 7/10
Location: Night Club

Apple Pin
Rareness: 7/10
Location: Pizza Parlor

Cactus Pin
Rareness: 7/10
Location: Coffee Shop

Teddy Bear Pin
Rareness: 6.5/10
Location: Cave

Ice Cube Pin
Rareness: 6.5/10
Location: Ice Berg

Shrimp Pin
Rareness: 6.5/10
Location: Dance Lounge

Pot of Gold Pin
Rareness: 6.5/10
location: Ski Lodge Attic

Box Pin
Rareness: 6/10
Location: Dock

Microphone Pin
Rareness: 6/10
Location: Beacon

Ruby Pin
Rareness: 6/10
Location: Ski Village

Tulip Pin
Rareness: 5.5/10
Location: Sport Shop

Starfish Pin
Rareness: 5.5/10
Location: Mine

Surf Board Pin
Rareness: 5.5/10
Location: Beacon

Picnic Basket Pin
Rareness: 5/10
Location: Ski Lodge

Water Drop Pin
Rareness: 5/10
Location: Dance Lounge

Cart Surfer Pin
Rareness: 4.5/10
Location: Pizza Parlor

Butterfly Pin
Rareness: 4.5/10
Location: Forest

Tent Pin
Rareness: 4/10
Location: Mine Shack

BaseBall Pin
Rareness: 4/10
Location: Boiler Room

JellyFish Pin
Rareness: 4/10
Location: Ski Lodge

Circus Tent Pin
Rareness: 4/10
Location: Plaza at fall fair

PaddleBall Pin
Rareness: 3.5/10
Location: Snow Forts

HairBrush Pin
Rareness: 3.5/10
Location: Pet Shop

Spider Pin
Rareness: 3.5/10
Location: Cave

UFO Pin
Rareness: 3/10
Location: Dance Lounge

Needle Pin
Rareness: 3/10
Location: Cove

Holly Pin
Rareness: 3/10
Location: Coffee Shop

Wreath Pin
Rareness: 3/10
Location: Ski Lodge Attic

Snow Shovel Pin
Rareness: 3/10
Location: Boiler Room
This is Club Penguins 50th Pin

Sombrero Pin
Rareness: 2.5/10
Location: Forest

Rowboat Pin
Rareness: 2.5/10
Location: Lighthouse

Anchor Pin
Rareness: 2.5/10
Location: Cove

Golden Ship Wheel Pin
Rareness: 2/10
Location: Beat Aqua Grabber

Aqua Grabber Pin
Rareness: 2/10
Location: Cave

Book Pin
Rareness: 2/10
Location: Boiler Room

Crayon Pin
Rareness: 2/10
Location: Mine Shack

Pyramid Pin
Rareness: 2/10
Location: Book Room

Treasure Chest Pin
Location: Ski Village
Rareness: 2/10

Captain’s Quarters Key Pin
Location: Rockhopper’s Journal
Rareness: 2/10
ON STOCK IN CLUB PENGUIN LOCATED IN ROCKHOPPER’S JOURNAL

Goblet Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Rareness: 1.5/10

Anvil Pin
Location: Boiler Room
Rareness: 1.5/10

Ice Cream Cone Pin
Location: Forest
Rareness: 1.5/10

Basketball Pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Rareness: 1.5/10

Firework Rocket Pin
Location: Cove
Rareness: 1/10

Treble Clef Pin
Location: Cave
Rareness: 1/10
ON STOCK IN CLUB PENGUIN LOCATED IN THE CAVE